Late October is the most joyous and also the most stressful time of the blogging year for me. On one hand, the Super-Crafty Halloween Costume Contest is our favorite audience participation event. It’s very creative, always surprising and even most of the trolls seem to begrudgingly enjoy themselves.
Baby Gaga says: Thanks mom for not going with the gown made of meat.
Courtesy Sarah Morton
Baby Gaga says: “Thanks mom for not going with the gown made of meat.”
On the other, so many of the handmade costumes are amazing that it’s nearly impossible to pick winners. In the end, the judging feels almost arbitrary.
With that said, screw all of you. Below are the first entries in the Super-Crafty Halloween Costume Contest, and they’re better than ever. Great to see several entries in the group theme division. I was also happy to hear from multiple long-time The Poop readers who said they made their costumes in part because of the contest. I’ll be adding more throughout the week — check back often! Look for a full list of contestants on Monday and we’ll announce the winners some time later next week.
For those who are new, the Super-Crafty Halloween Costume Contest was created three years ago after a discussion on The Poop about the lost art of making costumes by hand among this generation of busy parents. The rules for the contest are here. In previous years, I haven’t been able to post all of the entrants because of technical issues and sheer volume. But if yours doesn’t get posted, feel free to send me a reminder at phartlaub@sfchronicle.com.
Thanks to everyone who has entered so far! Enjoy the craftiness!

Courtesy Jody Knight
Home made, Kia Superbowl commercial crew. How do you like me now?
Thanks,
Jody Knight

Courtesy Kirsten Macintyre
Hi Peter,
Attached are my kids’ Halloween costumes for this year. Kate (9) is the Cracker Jack sailor, and her brother Alex (7) is the toy surprise in the Cracker Jack box.
Kate is a Scottish highland dancer, so her sailor getup does double-duty (she wears it year-round for performances). It was her idea to make her brother into a toy surprise. He objected to the idea until I told him the adults would think it was cute and he’d get more candy. Then he was all for it.
Alex’s costume is made with about $5 in materials: Batting, duct tape and a few enlargements on the copy machine.
Kirsten Macintyre
PS: In researching this, I discovered that the sailor’s name is officially “Jack” (well, duh) and the dog’s name is “Bingo.” Who knew?

Courtesy Linda Baker
The cutest Jimmy Hendrix you’ll ever see!!!
Thank you,

Courtesy Allison Pretto
Hi P-Fresh,
Here is James Edward “Cookie” Prater, 18 months, in his chocolate chip cookie costume for Halloween 2010.
The backstory on this is as follows:
When our third son arrived, we named him James, but by the time he was nine months old, he was known to one and all as “Cookie,” because he is so darn sweet. (I don’t think the third kid has a choice but to be really agreeable.)
This year there was never any doubt what Cookie would be for Halloween. Cookie had to be a cookie! The problem was, I could find only one ready-made cookie costume. It was at Pottery Barn and cost $59.99. I KNOW!!!!
I figured, considering the fact that a cookie costume is basically a bunch of CIRCLES SEWN TOGETHER, even *I* could do better (or at least cheaper) than Pottery Barn. And so, here you see the result. I sent the second shot so that you could get an idea of the construction: The cookie costume is basically two felt pillows connected with ties, sandwich-board style.
For the record, Cookie appreciates his costume. He walks around gleefully announcing, “Coo-kee!”
Sincerely,
Allison Pretto
San Leandro

Courtesy Rosalie Shaw
My younger son told me he wanted to be a Giant’s Foam finger. The costume was all his idea; since I had to buy so much orange paint I had leftover and my older son wanted to be a “Lego” and he was fine with it being orange too!
Rosalie Shaw

Courtesy Keelie Duncan
Here is my 7 month old Penelope wearing her Twink the sprite costume. I handmade her costume using a pattern I drafted up. It took a ton of trial and error but it turned out adorable! This Halloween she makes the perfect sidekick to my own Rainbow Brite attire.
-Keelie

Courtesy Jody Handley
You’ll have to believe me that I made this this week. (check my blog for details!) Thanks so much for this contest, by the by — it’s what finally fully inspired me to take the crafty plunge.

Courtesy Esme Shaller
Hi Peter,
As always, the Poop continues to be amazing, so thank you. I have been MIA from the comments for the last few months because we went ahead and had a second kid and as you know, things got busy! HOWEVER, the silver lining is that you have unveiled the group division category just in time for my two daughters to enter.
Longtime Poop readers may remember me as the mom who dressed her baby as an ear of corn back in 2008. All of my costumes are basically glue gun and felt, so once next year hits and the will-be-three year old makes a request, I hope it’s another inanimate object, preferably food.
Here are Keely, two, and June, four months. Keely is a slice of strawberry-rhubarb pie, and June is the a la mode. The hardest part about this project was getting the two of them and the costumes all presentable in one photo, so I have attached 3 for you to choose from — one of just the costumes, one of both of them in them that is in focus, and one that is a little fuzzy but I had to send just do you could see how much fun they were having. The pie looks better standing up, but I couldn’t incorporate the baby that way, so whatever.
Keep up the great work and Happy Halloween!
Esme Shaller

Courtesy Llela Tan-Walsh
Hi Peter,
Our soon to be 3-year old son (Blaise) is into Super Mario Brothers since my husband bought the video game early this month. We decided that he will be cute as one of the toadstool mushroom (the blue one) instead of the typical mario or luigi. Everything was hand crafted except for the white turtle neck and pants. I tried to take a picture of my son with today’s “The Poop” with Mike Adamick’s Frances England blog.
Regards,
Llela

Courtesy Brent Woodard
Peter,
Attached you will find our take on the Star Wars group. Especially take note of “Luke Skywalker” and “Yoda” in the front row — these are my godchildren, who I make costumes for each year for their birthday which happens in October. I got especially good reviews for my Yoda feet. Unfortunately, “Luke” isn’t wearing the boots that were made for the costume because we are in-doors.
Also part of the group — “Uncle Owen”, “Aunt Beru”, “Obi-wan”, “Darth Vader”, “Princess Leia”, a pregnant “Han Solo”, “Anakin Skywalker” (which is me), and “George Lucas.”
Thanks,
Brent Woodard

Anonymous
… Those are chopsticks in her hair.
.
Courtesy Crystal Keene
Hey Peter,
This is a photo I took last Halloween of my son dressed as Jango Fett and his dog Caesar dressed as Yoda. I thought it was fitting after the recent post. Also WirelessAndy asked if there was a photo floating around.
Lasvegasmom aka Crystal
.
.
Courtesy Heather Summerer

Courtesy Heather Summerer
Attached is the original chick costume worn in 2005. I remade it to fit my second child in 2009. It is two onesies sewn together at the legs and neck after being stuffed with batting. Take feather boas and wind them around use big slip stitches to hold them in place. In 2009, my oldest daughter wanted to be a pig, Mom was a cow and Dad was farmer. I learned quick to get to the house at the same time as my daughter or she would announce to my neighbors … “My Mom is a cow!” Nice. Made the pig too. My husband is a saint.
Heather Summerer
.
Courtesy Debbie Lee
It’s a little early, but here is my daughter’s costume for this year. She’s a California roll, because when I was pregnant with her I always craved sushi but was never allowed to eat it (apparently imitation crabmeat = sandwich meat = risk of listeria).
Debbie
.
Courtesy Sarah Morton
Baby Gaga …
.
.
Courtesy Amy Alamar
It started with a pumpkin. I had my first child and had just learned to sew and I was set on making my baby the cutest pumpkin ever! How else would I call him pumpkin with any integrity? So, I set in motion, first the fabric store, next another fabric store that had better orange felt. The construction process, with my mother’s help of course, took about two full days as I recall. But, then there was securing a matching fabric dye for the long johns to be worn underneath — not to mention the socks. Lo and behold, he was the great pumpkin Charlie Brown! It became tradition, each August my mother and I would set out to make Halloween costumes before my mother would head home for football season.
Fast forward, one daughter, one son, three nephews, and one niece later … The kids wanted “Star Wars,” so we went “Star Wars.” My mother had to sit this one out, but thank goodness my Aunt was in town and is very handy with altering patterns, because, while it may come as a surprise, they don’t sell Chewbacca and R2D2 costume patterns.
Now here’s the kicker: My aunt goes back to DC and my curmudgeon of a brother-in-law who will never dress up pipes in, “Ooh, make me an Emperor Costume.” So in addition to seven wee costumes (two not pictured because they live in LA) I made two XL ones (my husband and brother-in-law), mind you, the sleeves of the XL cloaks were larger than my 5 foot frame.
Take care,
Amy Alamar
.
.
PETER HARTLAUB is the pop culture critic at the San Francisco Chronicle and founder of this parenting blog, which admittedly sometimes has nothing to do with parenting. You can follow him on Twitter at www.twitter.com/peterhartlaub.
Read more: http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/blogs/parenting/detail?entry_id=75451#ixzz13XcmB8CR
admin For Life, Fun
Recent Comments